A church destroyed. A congregation silenced. A relationship shattered. Yet even in lifes darkest valleys, a small flame can light the way toward healing and hope. A deadly fire rips through St. James Church, devastating the congregation and Pastor Dave. Adjoining Hadleigh University uses the tragedy to kick the congregation off campus. The escalating controversy creates a dilemma for the small church-can Christians fight for their rights and be the light for Christ at the same time? Facing a court case and his own struggle to see Christs light in heartbreak, Dave asks for help from Pearce, his estranged brother-a big-city lawyer and an atheist-to fight for the churchs right to exist. The family reunion opens old wounds, as the brothers wrestle with the questions that pulled them apart years ago: Is God really good all the time? Where is God when bad things happen? Can Christ really heal the brokenhearted?